My favourite mascara is no secret. In fact, I've been pretty vocal about my obsession for Cover Girl's The Super Sizer mascara, both here and on my YouTube channel. The reason is simple: it works. That drugstore product adds tons of length, volume, and drama to the lashes. Since it is a holy grail product for me, I rarely think to try other mascaras on the market. I simply don't need to. That being said, during a Sephora VIB event a while back, two mascara samples were included in the goodie bag. One was from Laura Mercier and the other from Benefit. Find out how they perform and which one is worth the splurge...
High End Mascara Face Off: Laura Mercier
The first mascara in this high end mascara face off comes from Laura Mercier. This is the Caviar Volume mascara and it claims to thicken and add intense volume to the lashes in one bold stroke. Does it? Actually, yes. This mascara adds a wonderful amount of length and volume to the lashes. It looks wonderful when applied and one coat is really all you need. That being said, the wand is a bit clunky to use. (I personally prefer something sleeker, similar to The Super Sizer or They're Real!) This mascara would work well for an everyday look or if you want lashes with lots of look-at-me-length.
High End Mascara Face Off: Benefit
Next up is the Roller Lash mascara from Benefit. This is a brand that I have a little more experience with because I used to use their They're Real! mascara constantly. That and Dior Show were my ultimate favourites. So needless to say, I was curious to see how the Roller Lash would perform. First off, this has a really unique wand and its curved shape makes application much easier. I definitely prefer this style to the chunky Laura Mercier one. As for how the mascara performs, I was really impressed. It adds a lot of length and volume - and creates fluttery, flirty looking lashes. The fact that this makes your lashes look extra dark is also a real benefit.
High End Mascara Face Off: The Verdict
As you can see from the picture above, there are only slight differences between the two mascaras. Both perform quite well, if you ask me. However, the Benefit snags the win thanks to the excellent wand design, the added length on the lower lashes (the wand made application on the lower lashes so much easier), the darker colour, and the fluttery finish it gives the lashes. They just seem to have more movement while the Laura Mercier mascara seems somewhat stiff. Though both are quality products, Benefit is the one I would consider purchasing a full sized version of in future.
The Winner: Benefit Roller Lash
Have you tried either of these? What is your favourite high end mascara?
WOW! Adorable mascara. I like it... kissesReplyDelete
Yes, they were both impressive! Thanks for visiting.Delete
Good review 😊 thanks for your sharing 😊ReplyDelete
Aww thank you!Delete
thanks for the comment <3ReplyDelete
i love roller lash :D
It performed really well! Thank you for stopping by!Delete
Hi dear! I love the mascara Benefit, your eyelashes are more defined and voluminous in a natural way!ReplyDelete
Yes, I totally agree! It's a really good mascara!Delete
Both look similar but I think the Roller Lash looks a little better! I have only ever tried Barry M Mascara!ReplyDelete
Agree! It's really a slight difference but I do prefer the slightly darker colour and the applicator of the Roller Lash. I haven't tried that mascara, is it good??Delete
This was a good comparison! While I've never tried the Laura Mercier one before I do love the Benefit roller lash! I got a sample of it once and had to go buy a full size one, haha!ReplyDelete
Hope that you are having a good week :)
Away From Blue | Handbag Gift Guide
Yes, I can fully understand why! If I'm looking for a high end mascara to mix things up (my favourite mascara ever is from Cover Girl, shockingly enough) this is one I would choose. Thank you so much!Delete
This is a great comparison, Shannon! Can't believe how much the added length on the lower lashes from the Benefit one really made a difference IMO.ReplyDelete
My fave high end mascara will always be Chanel but man.... just can't justify paying for the price!!!
Agree! Ooh how is the Chanel one? I've never even dared to look at their beauty products because of the price tag - but I'm certain everything would be gorgeous!Delete
Such a nice review! They both did a good job but i would agree that Benefit won :)ReplyDelete
Glad you agree! Thank you so much for visiting :)Delete
Very great review.ReplyDelete
Thank you so much!Delete
Thanks for your honest and detailed review.ReplyDelete
Aww I really appreciate that!Delete
A fine mascara is a must to me. I need to try your favorite tooReplyDelete
It is definitely worth trying! I absolutely love the formula.Delete
Idk why do I like the roller lash more than one another hahahaReplyDelete
I like it more too, so I feel you on that!Delete